Butterfly switches, designed and patented by Apple, are a type of keyboard mechanism used in their MacBook laptops. These switches were first introduced in 2015 with the release of the 12-inch MacBook and have since been implemented in all newer models.
Butterfly switches are known for their thinness, lightness, and responsiveness compared to traditional scissor switches used in most laptops. This innovative design has allowed Apple to create even thinner and lighter laptops while maintaining a high level of typing precision.
In this article, we will explore the history of butterfly switches, their technology and functionality, and how they have impacted the overall user experience of MacBook users. We will also discuss some common criticisms and issues related to butterfly switches and how Apple has addressed them. So let’s dive into the world of butterfly switches and discover what makes them so unique and popular among laptop users.
History of Butterfly Switches
Butterfly switches were first introduced by Apple in 2015 as a replacement for the traditional scissor switches used in their laptops. The design of butterfly switches was patented by Apple and developed in collaboration with a Japanese company, Nissha, who specializes in producing computer and phone keyboards. This partnership helped Apple to create a keyboard mechanism that was incredibly thin and light, yet still provided a responsive typing experience.
The first generation of butterfly switches were featured in the 12-inch MacBook, and they quickly gained popularity due to their sleek design and improved functionality. The second-generation butterfly switches were introduced in 2016 with the release of the redesigned MacBook Pro models. These newer switches offered more stability and responsiveness compared to the original butterfly switches, making them even more popular among users.
In 2018, Apple released a third generation of butterfly switches, which were featured in the MacBook Air and revised versions of the MacBook Pro. This new generation addressed some common criticisms of the previous versions, such as keys being easily damaged by dust and debris. However, these switches still faced backlash from some users for their shallow key travel and lack of tactile feedback.
Technology and Functionality
The technology behind butterfly switches is quite different from traditional scissor switches. Instead of a single hinge, butterfly switches have two metal hinges that interlock with one another and provide greater stability to the keys. This design also allows for a thinner profile, as the keys can be placed closer together.
The keycaps on butterfly switches are made of polycarbonate material and coated with polyurethane to prevent wear and tear. The switches also use a dome-shaped structure under each key, which enables them to be more responsive and require less force for actuation.
One of the most significant advantages of butterfly switches is their low-profile design, allowing for a thinner and lighter laptop. This makes them ideal for Apple’s goal of creating sleek and portable devices. Additionally, the stability provided by the double hinge mechanism ensures that keys do not wobble or get stuck, providing a more consistent and precise typing experience.
How Butterfly Switches have Impacted User Experience
Butterfly switches have had a significant impact on the overall user experience of MacBook users. The low-profile design has allowed Apple to create thinner and lighter laptops without sacrificing keyboard functionality. This has been particularly beneficial for those who travel frequently or use their laptops on-the-go.
The increased stability and responsiveness of butterfly switches have also improved the typing experience for many users. The keys feel more solid and precise, giving a better sense of control while typing. Additionally, the shallow key travel allows for faster typing speeds, making these keyboards ideal for those who type frequently.
However, butterfly switches have also faced criticism from some users who prefer a more tactile feedback while typing. The low-profile design and lack of key travel can make it feel like typing on a touchscreen rather than a traditional keyboard. This has led some users to prefer older MacBook models with scissor switches or to opt for external keyboards.
Also, the initial versions of butterfly switches were prone to damage from dust and debris, causing keys to become stuck or unresponsive. While Apple has made improvements in subsequent generations, this issue is still a concern for some users.
Criticisms and How Apple Addressed Them
Despite their popularity, butterfly switches have faced some criticisms from users. One of the main complaints was the lack of tactile feedback and shallow key travel, which made typing feel less natural for some users. This led to discomfort and even pain while using the keyboard for extended periods.
To address these issues, Apple introduced a third generation of butterfly switches with a silicone membrane barrier in 2018. This membrane was designed to prevent dust and debris from entering the keys, reducing the chances of key failure or malfunction. Additionally, this new design also provided a slightly more tactile feel to the keyboard.
In early 2020, Apple announced that they would be phasing out butterfly switches completely and returning to the traditional scissor switches for their laptops. This decision was made in response to continued criticism and issues with butterfly switches.
Also, with the release of the 16-inch MacBook Pro in late 2019, Apple introduced a new and improved scissor switch design called the Magic Keyboard. This keyboard has been well-received by users for its improved key travel, tactile feedback, and more durable construction.
Can We Expect to See Butterfly Switches Again?
It is unlikely that butterfly switches will make a comeback in future Apple laptops. The company has already discontinued their use and moved on to scissor switches for all current MacBook models. However, it is possible that the technology behind butterfly switches could be improved upon and resurface in different forms.
For example, other companies have already started using similar double hinge mechanisms in their keyboards, such as Microsoft’s Surface Pro lineup. It is also possible that Apple could incorporate some aspects of butterfly switches into future keyboard designs, such as the low-profile design and increased stability.
Plus, Apple is constantly researching and developing new technologies for their products, so it’s possible that they may come up with a completely new keyboard design that surpasses both butterfly and scissor switches in terms of functionality and user experience.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Are butterfly switches still available on any current Apple products?
No, butterfly switches have been completely discontinued by Apple and replaced with scissor switches on all current MacBook models.
Will other companies start using butterfly switches now that Apple has discontinued them?
It is possible, but highly unlikely. Other companies may have been inspired by the design of butterfly switches, but with Apple’s decision to move away from them and towards scissor switches, it is unlikely that other companies will invest in a similar mechanism. Additionally, the patent for butterfly switches is owned by Apple, making it difficult for other companies to use them without infringing on intellectual property rights.
Is there a noticeable difference in typing experience between butterfly switches and scissor switches?
Yes, there is a noticeable difference in typing experience between the two. Butterfly switches are known for their stability and responsiveness, while scissor switches offer more tactile feedback and longer key travel. It ultimately depends on personal preference and typing habits.
- LEAN. MEAN. M3 MACHINE — With a powerful 8-core CPU and 10-core GPU, the blazing-fast MacBook Air with M3 chip is a superportable laptop that sails through work and play.
- BUILT FOR APPLE INTELLIGENCE—Apple Intelligence is the personal intelligence system that helps you write, express yourself, and get things done effortlessly. With groundbreaking privacy protections, it gives you peace of mind that no one else can access your data—not even Apple.*
- PORTABLE DESIGN — Lightweight and under half an inch thin, so you can take MacBook Air anywhere you go.
- UP TO 18 HOURS OF BATTERY LIFE — Amazing, all-day battery life so you can leave the power adapter at home.
- A BRILLIANT DISPLAY — The 13.6-inch Liquid Retina display supports 1 billion colors.
- LEAN. MEAN. M3 MACHINE — With a powerful 8-core CPU and up to 10-core GPU, the blazing-fast MacBook Air with M3 chip is a superportable laptop that sails through work and play.
- BUILT FOR APPLE INTELLIGENCE—Apple Intelligence is the personal intelligence system that helps you write, express yourself, and get things done effortlessly. With groundbreaking privacy protections, it gives you peace of mind that no one else can access your data—not even Apple.*
- PORTABLE DESIGN — Lightweight and under half an inch thin, so you can take MacBook Air anywhere you go.
- UP TO 18 HOURS OF BATTERY LIFE — Amazing, all-day battery life so you can leave the power adapter at home.
- MORE ROOM FOR WHAT YOU LOVE — The 15.3-inch Liquid Retina display supports 1 billion colors.
- Renewed products look and work like new. These pre-owned products have been inspected and tested by Amazon-qualified suppliers, which typically perform a full diagnostic test, replacement of any defective parts, and a thorough cleaning process. Packaging and accessories may be generic. All products on Amazon Renewed come with a minimum 90-day supplier-backed warranty.
- 1.6 GHz dual-core Intel Core i5 (Turbo Boost up to 2.7 GHz) with 3 MB shared L3 cache
- 4 GB of 1600 MHz LPDDR3 RAM, 128 GB PCIe-based flash storage
- 11.6-Inch (diagonal) LED-backlit Glossy Widescreen Display, 1366 x 768 px resolution
- STRIKINGLY THIN DESIGN — The redesigned MacBook Air is more portable than ever and weighs just 2.7 pounds. It’s the incredibly capable laptop that lets you work, play or create just about anything — anywhere.
- SUPERCHARGED BY M2 — Get more done faster with a next-generation 8-core CPU, up to 10-core GPU and up to 24GB of unified memory.
- BUILT FOR APPLE INTELLIGENCE—Apple Intelligence is the personal intelligence system that helps you write, express yourself, and get things done effortlessly. With groundbreaking privacy protections, it gives you peace of mind that no one else can access your data—not even Apple.*
- UP TO 18 HOURS OF BATTERY LIFE — Go all day and into the night, thanks to the power-efficient performance of the Apple M2 chip.
- BIG, BEAUTIFUL DISPLAY — The 13.6-inch Liquid Retina display features over 500 nits of brightness, P3 wide color and support for 1 billion colors for vibrant images and incredible detail.
Final Thoughts
In conclusion, butterfly switches may have been short-lived in the world of technology, but their legacy and impact will always be remembered. While scissor switches seem to be the preferred choice for now, it’s important to keep an open mind towards new keyboard designs and improvements in technology.
And with Apple constantly striving for better user experience, we can only expect even more innovative and ergonomic keyboard designs in the future. Ultimately, it’s up to individual preferences and needs, and the freedom of choice that makes technology so exciting and ever-evolving.
So whether you’re a fan of butterfly switches or not, we can all appreciate their contributions to the evolution of keyboards. As they say, “out with the old, in with the new” – but who knows, we may just see a comeback of butterfly switches in the future. Until then, let’s continue typing away on our scissor switch and Magic Keyboards, appreciating the best of both worlds.